Butcher Box Reviews And Our Honest Opinions!

Variety of fruits

Image source: Unsplash.com

Butcher Box Reviews And Our Honest Opinions!

Unless you are a vegetarian, meat is an essential part of your diet. Finding and getting quality meat can be difficult at times. Imagine getting quality meat to come right to your door?

That’s what Butcher Box is all about.

With so many subscriptions services available, ranging from cosmetics to premade meals, why not have one for meat?

Is it worth it? Is the meat that good? We will be answering those questions and more in this review.

What Is Butcher Box And How Does It Work?

It’s a monthly subscription service that delivers a month’s worth of meat right to your door. The company isn’t a farm or a supermarket. They act as a middle man that works with farmers. You get to pick from beef, chicken, or pork and the size of the box.

All the boxes are well insulated and have dry ice so that meat is still good by the time it gets to your door. Each piece of meat is individually vacuum sealed.

If you aren’t sure what to do with all this meat, they offer recipes that you can use.

You have a variety of options when it comes to what kind of meat and box size you want. Though know that what you get can change by where you live and what’s availability. Currently, Butcher Box offers:

  • The Mixed Box features a variety of meat across all three animals. You don’t get to choose what you get, the people at Butcher Box choose for you. An example of what you can get is two pounds of ground beef, 2 NY strip steaks, 4 top sirloin steaks, one pound of whole pork tenderloin, and three pounds of boneless, skinless, chicken breasts.
  • The Beef & Pork Box features only beef and pork, and once again Butcher Box chooses for you. An example of what the box can have is two pounds of ground beef, two NY strip steaks, four top sirloin steaks, four boneless pork chops, and two pounds of whole pork tenderloin.
  • The Beef & Chicken Box features beef and chicken of Butcher Box’s choice. An example is getting two pounds of ground beef, two NY strip steaks, four top sirloin steaks, three pounds of boneless, skinless chicken breasts, and three pounds of chicken drumsticks.
  • The All Beef Box features beef of Butcher Box’s choice. You could get two pounds of ground beef, two NY strip steaks, one premium steak tip, two or more pounds of chuck roast, and four top sirloin steaks as an example.
  • The Custom Box lets you get to pick from twenty-one different cuts. There’s twenty percent more meat than the other boxes. You get full control with this box.

You can also buy add-ons, which are extra cuts of meat. These extras can include bacon, pork chops, burgers, and NY strips.

As for box sizes, you get two choices. You can get the classic box that holds eight to eleven pounds of meat, and equates twenty-four meals. Then there is the big box. It can hold sixteen to twenty-two pounds of meat, which equals forty-eight meals.

What Makes Butcher Box Unique

Butcher Box is different because the meat they offer isn’t the kind you get at the supermarket. All their beef is grass-fed and grass-finished, their pork is a heritage breed, and they offer free-range organic chicken.

They want to know about every aspect of the animals’ lives. They make sure that the animals that turn into meat are treated fairly and humanely. They believe the quality of life makes the quality of meat.

Their beef is a hundred grass-fed and grass-finished. The cows have been pasture raised and allowed to roam as they like. The beef is full of nutrients, vitamins, and minerals.

Their pork comes from pigs that have bedding in open barns and plenty of time outside. They are fed an all vegetarian diet.

Their chicken meat comes from chickens that live in barns and can go outside anytime they want. They are given an all vegetarian diet.

Everything is taste tested by the people from the service.

They not only care about animals but the environment as a whole. All their packaging is a hundred percent recyclable or compostable.

The Big Deal About Grass-Fed Meat

Butcher Box shows off the fact that they have grass-fed meat. Many people prefer it over the kind of meat you get at the supermarket. For the most part, you don’t know where the meat comes from or what the animals have eaten beforehand.

What animals eat before they turn into meat have a bigger effect than you might think. It changes how healthy and nutritious meat can be.

Many health bloggers love to talk about how much healthier grass-fed meat is. They claim that it’s not only healthy but also good for the planet. Is it true or is it just hype?

Grass Fed Vs. Grass Finished Beef

Grass fed and grass finished are not the same thing. All cows are fed grass when they are first born. They have a diet of their mother’s milk and grass. Grass finished means that cows eat grass their whole life.

There is now an actual definition of what grass fed means. The USDA says that to be grass fed, animals have to eat grass and forage only after weaning off their mother’s milk. It doesn’t say how much food has to be grass. Other foods like hay and other forage are allowed.

Is grass better for cows? You probably think about cows roaming on hills on a farm. Grass is a bit healthier. Grain is described as cake or ice cream for cows. Though, like with people, cows shouldn’t only eat grain. They should have a more balanced diet.

Too much grain can cause pH levels in cows to become too acidic. That can make cows pretty sick.

As for grass fed being better for the planet, it’s a bit of a toss-up. Meat, in general, isn’t great for the planet because cattle create methane, which is a harsh greenhouse gas. Some people believe you should eat less meat to help with climate change.

Though like anything else, good management is key.

Different Types Of Beef

Not all beef is the same. Depending on what cows are fed can change how they taste and how nutritious they are. There are some large differences between what types of food you feed cows and how it affects the beef.

Is grass fed the best though?

Grass-Fed Vs. Grain-Fed

In the US, cows are fed grains more than grass. After young cows wean from their mothers, they move to a feedlot. Feedlots are called concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs).

Grains will cause animals to get fat quickly. The grains are usually made from soy or corn. Animals do get a little bit of grass, but it’s mostly grains.

To get the animals as big as possible, they are given antibiotics and growth hormones.

This means that when you have that meat, you are exposed to the diet and drugs the animals have had as well.

Grass-fed animals tend to have less fat than grain fed. This can also mean that grass-fed meat has fewer calories. The fatty acids are different too.

  • Grass-fed meat has less monounsaturated fat than grain-fed meat.
  • Grass-fed and grain fed meat have close to the same amount of omega-6 fatty acids.
  • Grass-fed can have five times as omega-3.
  • Grass-fed meat has around twice the amount of conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) as grain fed beef.
  • Both grass and grain fed meat are filled with nutrients. They have B12, B3, B6, iron, selenium, and zinc.
  • Grass-fed meat has more Vitamin A and E.

Grass-Fed Vs. Organic

You would think that grass-fed and organic are the same thing. They aren’t. All grass-fed meat is organic, but not all organic is grass-fed.

With organic meat, animals can be fed organic grain. Though, organic meat isn’t pumped with antibiotics and growth hormones.

What All The Chicken Labels Mean

There are a lot of different labels when it comes to buying eggs. What do they all mean and what is the best?

Also, is Butcher Box’s free-range organic eggs the best?

Free-Range Vs. Cage Free Chicken

Free-range is all about chickens being outside for around half their life. It doesn’t have any rules about what the chickens eat or how much time they get outside. As long as they have access to the outdoors, they can be called free-range.

Being outside is important because they get fresh air, sunshine, and can interact with other chickens.

Also, there are no specific size specifications to be considered free range.

Cage-free sounds good on paper, but it’s not as free as you think. Yes, they aren’t in cages, but they are all in a single space. Very similar to caged chickens, there is little room for the chickens to stretch their wings.

Cage-free does allow more natural behavior, stronger bones, and more feathers.

Free range eggs make healthier eggs than cage-free. This is due to having less stress because they go outside. They tend to have less cholesterol, saturated fat, more vitamin A, more omega 3, more vitamin E, and more beta-carotene.

Free Range Vs. Organic Chicken

The term organic is often associated with quality of life for chickens, but that’s not always the case. The organic label is earned by following specific standards set by the government. It means that chemicals are not put in the chickens and they have some access to the outdoors.

As mentioned before, free range doesn’t equal organic.

These labels focus more on how the food is made, not the taste of the product. Organic food has a small amount more of nutritional value.

The most significant difference is personal preference. If you prefer to have your eggs from chickens that are outside more than not, then you want free range. If you don’t want any chemicals in your eggs, then go with organic.

Free Range Vs. Caged Chicken

Not to be too be preachy, but caged chickens do not have a good life. Caged production is the most common way to get eggs. These places are known as factory farms.

Caged chickens are packed into cages and are very unsanitary. Because of these conditions, they get sick more often and are more stressed out, which means that they need to be pumped with antibiotics.

Around average, six chickens will share the same cage. They also rarely go outside.

While free range doesn’t disclose what they eat, they at least get to go outside. You’d also like to think that free range chickens are treated to better food than caged chickens.

Different Types Of Pigs

There are different types of pigs out there. Some are better than others. Is Butcher Box’s choice of heritage the best choice?

Heritage Vs. Commercial

Heritage breed is different than your average pig. They have natural “old-world” genetics that slows their maturation process and causes them to get fine marbling and flavor.

They tend to be raised more humanely and are thought to be better for the environment. Also, heritage pigs tend to be pastured raised. This type of raising tends to be healthier, though not all pasture raised is heritage.

To be considered heritage, a pig needs:

  • True Genetic Breed—meaning that it mates with the same breed.
  • Endangered Breed—The breed is or has been endangered.
  • Long History in the US—the breed has been breeding since 1925.
  • Purebred Status—must be registered as purebred animals.
  • Meat has to be sold as heritage.
  • Managing Practices—raising the pigs according to their breed. This means what their diet is, letting them outside anytime, and no chemicals.


Pricing is where most people start to hesitate. For all the boxes that aren’t customized, the classic box costs $129 a month, and the big box is $238. The customized boxes cost $149 a month, and the big box is $270 a month.

While those prices seem extreme at first, if you break down the numbers by how many meals you can have, then each meal costs around six dollars.

Still, if you aren’t a huge meat fan, this could be too much. It also seems to work for smaller families. If you have a large family, the meals might not stretch out as far during the month.

If you don’t have a preference for what your meat is fed, then this will not be worth the price for you.

Luckily, you can cancel the subscription anytime if you find that it’s not worth the price.

Shipping is free too.

What Other People Think Of This Service

So, Butcher Box sounds great on paper, but does it deliver? Depending on the Butcher Box reviews, it can be the greatest thing or the worst. It appears to be very polarizing.

People have really loved how the meat tastes and how fresh it is. All their meat was packaged well and kept frozen. People also love the fact the animals are treated so well.

Sliced bacon on top of brown chopping board

Image source: Pexels

People also appreciate that the boxes are different every month so that they get to try different things. Many people with families can create amazing meals with meat from the subscriptions and the recipes they offer.

The biggest problem that reviewers have mentioned is that the customer service is terrible. People claim that representatives are rude and brush off customer concerns. These concerns range from packing problems to the boxes being on the smaller end of the scale all the time.

There also seems to be some problems with using coupons. Many people have tried to use promo codes and have them not work. When people tried to contact them, there always seemed to be some fine print that customers didn’t know about.

Then, of course, there is the price. Even the people who loved this service have been wary of using it more than once due to the price.

What We Think

Overall, we think that Butcher Box offers great quality meat for a fair price, but they need to get their act together. Many reviews even within the same month as writing these Butcher Box reviews have been full of complaints.

Complaints have mostly been about packaging and customer service. The idea of the meat not being properly package is scary. It could possibly make you sick at the worst, and at best, it will be a waste of money.

Having to contact the company all the time to get new meat is ridiculous. Mainly, because they generally don’t give refunds.

For a business to have bad customer service is foolish. So many reviewers have been offended with how they’ve been treated. Many have said the representatives have been rude, condescending, or just haven’t cared.

Many people’s problems aren’t resolved.

This subscription service has great potential, but they need to put as much care into their customer service and logistics as they do with their meat.

If Butcher Box gets their act together, it will be great. If you want to try it either now or in a bit, there are good and bad for certain people and lifestyles.


Butcher Box Is Good For

The subscription will suit you if you really care about where your meat comes from. It’s also good for you if you’re worried about the meat in your grocery stores.

Grilled meat dish served on white plate

Image source: Pexels

As mentioned before, Butcher Box makes sure their meat comes from animals that are grass-fed and have the best quality of life possible.  You can’t say the same about the meat you get at the supermarket.

It’s great if you want meat like from Butcher Box and can’t get it locally. Some places, you can go to a butcher or farm and get meat that way.

If you want to try more of a variety of food, Butcher Box is a great way to do so. Because you can only pick the kind of meat but not the cut, you will be forced to try new things. If you don’t try it, then it’s a waste of money.

Finally, it’s good for you if you’re too busy or just like the idea of getting meat right at your door and not having to go out.


Butcher Box Is Bad For

You don’t need this subscription if you can get good meat locally. Again, places like butchers, farms, or special grocery stores can offer you similar meat. If you have access to any of that, then you don’t really need the service.

If you want complete control, then this is not the subscription service for you, unless you always purchase a custom box every time. As a reminder, custom boxes are twenty more dollars than the regular ones.

Like when we talked about the pricing, if you eat a lot of meat or have a big family, then this may not be a good subscription for you. It will just get too expensive.


Coupons And Deals

As of writing these butcher box reviews, they are offering a special deal. You can get two free pounds of salmon and two filet mignons just by giving them your email.

Get It Together Butcher Box

It’s disappointing to see a company that cares so much about quality meat, animals, and the environment doing so poorly in the customer service department. You would think it would be easier to treat customers kindly than the work of finding such good meat.

They have lost a lot of customers due to a bad attitude and bad packaging.

If you really like high quality meat, it’s worth keeping an eye on this company. If they start getting better reviews, then you should try it. Until then, save your money.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here